Maine Approves Right-to-Repair Rules, Auto Lobby Annoyed

The State of Maine has joined the growing movement for right-to-repair legislation by approving Question 4, similar to the legislation passed in Massachusetts. This makes Maine the sixth state in the U.S. to pass such a measure, requiring automakers to standardize modern vehicle onboard diagnostic systems and make them accessible to customers and independent repair shops.

Victory for Right-to-Repair Movement

Maine residents overwhelmingly voted in favor of the measure, with approximately 84 percent supporting it. The new laws in Maine will mirror those in Massachusetts and other states, mandating that automakers equip vehicles sold in the state with a standardized access platform for telematics systems. This platform will provide owner-authorized access to all vehicle mechanical data through a mobile application. Additionally, the state’s attorney general will establish an independent entity to manage access to vehicle-generated mechanical data and ensure its security.

Auto Lobby’s Disappointment

The Alliance for Automotive Innovation (AAI), the world’s largest automotive lobby, expressed disappointment with the decision. John Bozzella, president and CEO of AAI, criticized out-of-state auto retailers for spending nearly $5 million to mislead Mainers about the implications of the right-to-repair legislation. Bozzella claimed that these retailers were primarily interested in accessing private vehicle telematics data to sell products, rather than advocating for true right-to-repair principles.

However, it’s worth noting that the automotive sector spends billions on lobbying and advertising each year, making the $5 million spent by retailers seem relatively insignificant.

Data Privacy Concerns

While the automotive lobby has previously argued that right-to-repair legislation could compromise cybersecurity, their claims are losing credibility. Automakers have been criticized for their poor protection of customer data, with a Mozilla Foundation study revealing that most automakers share data with third parties. Today’s vehicles generate and transmit a staggering amount of data, with an average of 25 gigabytes per hour. Many drivers are unaware that their data is being collected and shared.

As someone aligned with the right-to-repair movement, I oppose automakers’ practices regarding data procurement and vehicular connectivity. While I acknowledge the financial incentives for companies to harvest data, it is crucial to prioritize customer privacy and consent. The lack of government oversight on corporate monopolies allows businesses to expand into areas that were previously considered anti-competitive.

Maine Joins the Movement

The Maine Automotive Right to Repair Committee led the initiative, gathering over 70,000 signatures through a citizens’ petition. The opposition came from the Alliance for Automotive Innovation and the Maine Automobile Dealers Association. Supporters of Question 4 included grassroots organizations and industry names like the Coalition for Automotive Repair Equality, Advance Auto Parts, and AutoZone.

With Maine’s approval of right-to-repair legislation, the state has joined Massachusetts in modernizing automotive repair laws for the age of connected cars. The automotive lobby may be disappointed, but Mainers have made it clear that they want to protect their right to repair their vehicles.

[Image: Standret/Shutterstock]

Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by subscribing to our newsletter.