New VW Golf Takes on Toyota Corolla and Peugeot 308: A Triple Test
Introduction
Family hatchbacks are still a popular choice among car buyers, and three of the leading contenders in this segment are the Volkswagen Golf, Toyota Corolla, and Peugeot 308. While the Golf remains Volkswagen’s top-selling model in the UK, Toyota and Peugeot have seen success with smaller cars and crossovers. In this triple test, we will examine the facelifted Mk8 Golf and compare it to its rivals, the Corolla and 308.
The Facelifted Golf
The Mk8 Golf, launched in 2020, has faced criticism for its glitchy multimedia system, cheapened cabin, and touch-sensitive steering wheel buttons. However, Volkswagen has listened to feedback and made improvements in the facelifted version. The screen and software have been updated, the touch bar now lights up for nighttime use, and the interior has regained a sense of quality and tactility. The Golf still offers a compelling blend of space and driving manners.
The Peugeot 308
The Peugeot 308 stands out for its plush driving experience and French-inspired design. It offers a smooth and fluid drive, with a sense of lightness and simplicity. The 308 is equipped with a new hybrid powertrain, providing improved fuel economy and smoothness. While the interior design is visually appealing, the ergonomics and functionality of the i-Cockpit system can be challenging.
The Toyota Corolla
The Toyota Corolla has a no-nonsense approach and a reputation for reliability. Its interior may lack some of the design flair of its competitors, but it offers functional and durable features. The Corolla is equipped with a full hybrid drivetrain, delivering impressive fuel efficiency, especially in urban driving conditions. The Corolla’s driving experience is natural and harmonious, with light controls and precise handling.
Hybrid Powertrains
All three models in this triple test offer hybrid powertrains, providing improved fuel efficiency without the need for plug-in charging. The Golf features a mild hybrid system, while the Corolla has a full hybrid drivetrain. The 308 is described as a mild full hybrid, combining elements of both systems. Each model offers its own advantages in terms of fuel economy and performance.
Driving Experience
While none of these hatchbacks are considered true driver’s cars, they all offer enjoyable and capable driving experiences. They combine athleticism with impressive ride comfort, thanks to their lightweight construction and low center of gravity. The Corolla stands out for its natural and harmonious driving dynamics, while the Golf offers a versatile driving experience with the option of adaptive dampers. The 308’s handling is slightly hindered by its small steering wheel and muted feedback.
Verdict
In terms of hierarchy, the Peugeot 308 falls behind due to its ergonomic issues and higher price compared to its rivals. The choice between the Golf and Corolla is more challenging. The Golf offers a more upmarket and practical interior, while the Corolla feels easier and more natural to drive, with better fuel economy and adaptive cruise control. Ultimately, personal preference plays a significant role in choosing between the two. However, considering Toyota’s unmatched reliability record, the Corolla may be the safer long-term bet.
